Season 40

At just 13 years old, Trysten Mullis found his mother Amy on the ground with a corn rake sticking out of her back on their family's high farm. Now 21 years old, with his father behind bars for murder, Trysten speaks out for the first time and maintains that his father is innocent.

Judy Weaver was found murdered in her residence in Everett, Washington, in 1984. Decades later, a clever detective catches the elusive killer with a stick of gum.

Savannah Tolbert, 37, is found dead inside her car at a Huntsville, Alabama, strip mall in November 2022. Multiple surveillance cameras capture the final moments of what happened before a mysterious figure ends Savannah's life.

After Michael Harding is murdered and his wife Julie Harding is found dead, it feeds into a local legend of a "cursed" house in Celina, Tennessee.