Nerdy Prudes Must Die

Will Branner

Max Jägerman / Ensemble

Mariah Rose Faith Casillas

Stephanie Lauter / Caitlyn

Bryce Charles

Detective Shapiro / Brenda / PJ / Reporter

Corey Dorris

Mayor Solomon Lauter / Jason Jepson / Pokotho / Cop

Angela Giarratana

Grace Chasity / Drama Student

Lauren Lopez

Ruth Fleming / Donna Daggit / Emma Perkins / Bliklotep / Brooke

Jon Matteson

Richie Lipschitz / Boy Jerry / Trevor / Paul Matthews / Wiggog Y'Wrath / Student

Curt Mega

Officer Bailey / Mark Chasity / Kyle Clauger / T'noy Karaxis / News Announcer

Joey Richter

Peter Spankoffski / Dan Reynolds / Drama Student

Kim Whalen

Miss Mulberry / Karen Chasity / Reese / Miss Tessburger / Stacy / Nibblenephim